Our network

Inspectors Indicted in Kensington Towers Asbestos Probe | News

Title (Max 100 Characters)

Inspectors Indicted in Kensington Towers Asbestos Probe

BUFFALO, NY - A federal grand jury has indicted two companies and nine people, including past and present city and state inspection officials, in connection with an asbestos removal project at the vacant Kensington Towers housing project.

Three of the nine were serving as government inspectors at the time of the alleged crimes.

2 On Your Side's Dave McKinley says two officials with the City of Buffalo's Inspection Department are accused of falsely signing off that asbestos had been properly removed when, in fact, it had not been. One has since retired, but the other is still employed by the city. Another of those accused was an inspector with the new York State Department of Labor's Asbestos Control Bureau.

"I always want city employees to do the right thing," Buffalo Mayor Byron Brown told WGRZ-TV. "If they aren't they should suffer the consequences. But I just don't know enough about this incident to comment further," Mayor Brown said.

Whether the inspectors are alleged to have been lazy in the performance of their duties, or whether they were being compensated to look the other way, is something U.S Attorney William Hochul declined to comment on.

"I can't comment on the motive. All I can say is the indictment specifically says the grand jury found the false statements consisting of the false reports. But as to the reasons why the defendants engaged in this criminal conduct, that will have to wait for the development of evidence which is not in that document," Hochul said.

The contractors are charged with failing to remove and dispose of the asbestos properly, sometimes dumping it down holes cut in the floors of the six-building high-rise campus.

Prosecutors say the contractors did so despite knowing the buildings were scheduled for demolition, and that their actions could have exposed those nearby to the asbestos.

In that neighborhood is ECMC, a school, and a park.

"These are very serious charges," said U.S. Attorney William Hochul. "As I said before, asbestos is a highly-dangerous substance. The location where these buildings still stand speaks for itself."

The post World War II-era buildings, which are owned by the Buffalo Municipal Housing Authority, are being demolished to make way for a new senior citizen housing complex.

The indictment does not accuse the Buffalo Municipal Housing Authority of any wrongdoing. Its attorney tells 2 On Your Side the authority actually fired the indicted contractor long before these charges were filed. It has since hired a new company to remove the asbestos, and, according to the attorney, the towers are scheduled to be safely demolished within days.

The following is a press release issued by the United States Attorney's Office for Western New York:

.- U.S. Attorney William J. Hochul, Jr. announced today that a federal grand jury has returned a 23-count Indictment charging two companies and nine individuals with various federal felony charges relating to the asbestos abatement project conducted at the Kensington Towers apartment complex, 1827 Fillmore Avenue, Buffalo, New York. The companies charged with criminal violations are identified as Johnson Contracting of WNY, Inc. (Johnson Contracting) and JMD Environmental, Inc. (JMD). The individual defendants include Ernest Johnson, 39, and Rai Johnson, 32, both from Buffalo, NY and the President and Supervisor of Johnson Contracting (respectively); Evan Harnden, 42, a supervisor of JMD and Brian Scott, 31, JMD project monitor, both from North Tonawanda; and Henry Hawkins, 41, of Buffalo, NY and Chris Coseglia, 25, of Niagara Falls, NY; also project monitors of JMD.

The remaining defendants consist of current and former public officials responsible for certifying the project's compliance with applicable asbestos removal laws and regulations. Charged in the Indictment are Donald Grzebielucha, 56, and William Manuszewski, 57, both of Buffalo, NY, City of Buffalo Building Inspectors during the abatement project, and Theodore Lehmann, 65, of Kenmore, NY, an Inspector with the New York State Department of Labor, Asbestos Control Bureau.

Each of the 23 federal charges carry a maximum penalty of five years in prison, a fine of $250,000, or both.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Aaron J. Mango, who is responsible for the trial of the case, stated that the Indictment recognizes the federal Clean Air Act, along with the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), and other federal and state agencies, as closely regulating the removal of asbestos. The reasons for the law and regulations include that asbestos is a known human carcinogen known to cause a wide range of life threatening illnesses, including mesothelioma and asbestosis.

In June of 2009, Johnson Contracting was awarded a sub-contract to conduct the asbestos abatement project at Kensington Towers, a six-building complex owned by the Buffalo Municipal Housing Authority, located on the East side of Buffalo. In an environmental survey conducted before the commencement of the abatement project, it was estimated that each building at Kensington Towers contained in excess of 63,000 square feet of hazardous asbestos-containing material.

The Indictment alleges that from June 2009 to January 2010, defendants Johnson Contracting, Ernest Johnson, and Rai Johnson performed and supervised the stripping and removal of asbestos-containing material at the Kensington Towers. In Count 1, these defendants are accused of conspiring to violate the Clean Air Act and defrauding the United States, by (among other things) instructing workers to dump asbestos-containing debris down holes cut through the floors at the buildings, failing to wet the asbestos during removal operations, and instructing workers to leave asbestos-containing material in the buildings knowing that the buildings were intended for demolition. Counts 2 through 7 of the Indictment charge these defendants with substantive violations of the Clean Air Act for the above conduct.

In the same time period, defendants JMD, Harnden, Hawkins, Coseglia, and Scott, agreed to perform as a sub-contract of the abatement project the air sampling and project monitoring at Kensington Towers. Count 8 of the Indictment alleges that these defendants conspired to violate the Clean Air Act and to defraud the United States by (among other things) by failing to conduct proper air sampling, and by creating false visual inspection reports certifying that all asbestos had been removed from the buildings. Counts 9 through 14 of the Indictment charge these defendants with substantive violations of the Clean Air Act based on their roles as project monitors during the final visual inspection process at the buildings. Counts 15 through 17 charge defendants JMD and Hawkins with making and using false documents during the course of the asbestos abatement activities.

City of Buffalo Building Inspectors Donald Grzebielucha and William Manuszewski are charged in Counts 18 (defendant Grzebielucha) through 22 (defendant Manuszewski in Counts 19-22), with making and using false final inspection reports relating to all six of the buildings at Kensington Towers. The defendants specifically certified in the final inspection reports that all asbestos had been removed from the buildings, when in fact, the defendants knew that all asbestos had not been so removed.

Finally, Count 23 of the Indictment charges defendant Lehmann, an Inspector employed with the New York State Department of Labor, Asbestos Control Bureau, with concealing the improper asbestos abatement activities that were occurring at Kensington Towers.

"The nation's environmental laws are intended to protect not only people who live and work near abatement sites, but those employed in the abatement industry itself," said U.S. Attorney Hochul. "In this case, the Kensington Towers complex is in close proximity to a city neighborhood where people live as well as a hospital, a school and a park. This Office, along with its law enforcement partners, will continue to enforce laws designed to ensure the safety of all."

"Exposure to asbestos can be fatal. Its unsafe disposal endangers human health and can seriously harm the environment," said William V. Lometti, Special Agent in Charge of EPA's Criminal Investigation Division in New York. "The defendants are charged with conspiring to illegally allow large amounts of asbestos to be removed unsafely in an attempt to cut costs. Anyone who tries to save money by breaking the law will be vigorously prosecuted."

"This is a multi-agency investigation, and is a prime example of how working together with our state and federal partners ensures the safety of not only the Kensington Towers neighborhood but all Western New York communities," said Christopher M. Piehota, Special Agent in Charge of the Federal Bureau of Investigation. "The United States government takes very seriously the health and welfare of our citizens with regard to environmental safety."

The Indictment is the culmination of an investigation on the part of Special Agents of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency - Criminal Investigation Division, under the direction of Special Agent-In-Charge, William V. Lometti; Special Agents of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, under the direction of Special Agent-In-Charge Christopher M.. Piehota; Special Agents of the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development - Office of Inspector General, under the direction of Special Agent-In-Charge Rene Febles; and Investigators of the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation Police, BECI, under the direction of Captain David Bennett. Additional assistance was provided by the New York State Department of Labor, Asbestos Control Bureau.

The fact that a defendant has been charged with a crime is merely an accusation and the defendant is presumed innocent until and unless proven guilty.


Eastside Businesses